MLB The Show 25 is finally here, bringing fresh excitement to baseball gaming fans. One of the most beloved game modes is Road to the Show, where players create their own characters and climb the ranks from the minors to the major leagues. Your journey depends heavily on the team that drafts you—getting picked by a team stacked with strong starting pitchers could mean a long road to the majors. To help you make the best choice, here are the top teams to join as a starting pitcher.

MLB The Show 25 Unveils New Threads Program

The 2025 MLB offseason saw major player moves, from Juan Soto signing a record-breaking contract with the Mets to Roki Sasaki joining the Dodgers. To celebrate these shake-ups, MLB The Show 25 introduces the New Threads Program, featuring players who changed teams in the offseason. This program offers five Diamond Dynasty cards:

Jesus Lazardo (83 OVR)

Michael Conforto (84 OVR)

Jorge Soler (85 OVR)

Gleyber Torres (86 OVR)

Max Scherzer (88 OVR)

While fans speculated that Cody Bellinger or Anthony Santander would be the 88-rated Diamond headliner, it was revealed to be Max Scherzer, who joined the Blue Jays. However, Scherzer’s card lacks velocity and movement, making him a less-than-ideal pick for online play.

For those looking to enhance the game experience, upgrade your Diamond Dynasty squad—Buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs and dominate the competition!

Best Teams for a Starting Pitcher in Road to the Show

Road to the Show (RTTS) is one of the most beloved game modes in MLB The Show 25, offering players a deep and immersive career experience. In this mode, you create your own baseball player and guide them from the minor leagues to the major leagues, striving to become a superstar.

New to MLB The Show 25, RTTS now includes college teams, adding a more realistic pre-draft experience. Unlike other modes, RTTS focuses on player progression, allowing you to customize your athlete’s appearance, playstyle, and even their path to the MLB. You'll compete in games, improve your skills, and earn promotions based on your performance.

Your journey will depend on the team that drafts you—choosing a franchise with a weak roster at your position can help you reach the big leagues faster. Are you ready to become the next great ace? Pick your team wisely and dominate the mound in MLB The Show 25! Here are the best teams for aspiring aces:

1. New York Mets

Projected Starter: Manuel Margot (69 OVR)

Rotation:

Clay Holmes (RHP)

Tylor Megill (RHP)

Griffin Canning (RHP)

David Peterson (LHP)

Kodai Senga (RHP)

With injuries affecting their rotation and a powerhouse lineup featuring Juan Soto, the Mets offer a great chance for a starting pitcher to break into the majors quickly. Plus, run support won’t be an issue!

2. Baltimore Orioles

Opening Day Rotation:

Zach Eflin (RHP)

Charlie Morton (RHP)

Dean Kremer (RHP)

Tomoyuki Sugano (RHP)

Cade Povich (LHP)

After losing Corbin Burnes in free agency, the Orioles lack a true ace. This is a great opportunity to step in and take over as the leader of their rotation. The team’s explosive offense, led by Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman, will provide plenty of run support.

3. New York Yankees

Opening Day Rotation:

Carlos Rodón (LHP)

Max Fried (LHP)

Marcus Stroman (RHP)

Will Warren (RHP)

Carlos Carrasco (RHP)

With Gerrit Cole starting the season on the injured list, the Yankees’ rotation has openings that could allow a new pitcher to move up quickly. The challenge? Yankee Stadium is not pitcher-friendly, but with Aaron Judge in the lineup, offensive support will make your job easier.

Final Thoughts

MLB The Show 25 continues to improve Road to the Show, adding college teams and making the player journey more immersive. Choosing the right team as a starting pitcher is crucial for a fast track to the majors and a successful career. If you’re also into Diamond Dynasty, don’t forget to Buy MLB The Show 25 Accounts to get ahead in the game!